Skip to Content

Members' Research Report Archive

The Real Scene: Painting and Place in China, 1450–1550

Lihong Liu
A. W. Mellon Postdoctoral Fellow, 2014–2016

“Real scene” (shijing) denotes a process of mutual evocation of painting and place. As the mid-Ming critic Yang Shen (1488–1559) stated: “With an understanding of the landscape in mind, a real scene looks like a painting; created by dexterous hands, a painting looks like a real scene.” Since the fifteenth century, this notion has had abiding significance for painting practice and image theory, as well as for travel, sightseeing, and landscape design in China.

Qian Gu, Dao Hill Pavilion, in Zhu Ming xian shou Wen Zhengming bashi shihua ce (Various Ming Talents Celebrating Wen Zhengming’s Eightieth Birthday: An Album of Poetry and Painting), 1549, album leaf (1 of 15). Chen Chi-te Collection, Taipei. Photograph courtesy of Chen Chi-te

My book explores the foundational moment of pictorial articulation of, and critical thinking about, this important cultural concept. The mid-Ming period (c. 1450–1550) of the Ming dynasty (1368–1644) heralded the “silver century” (1550–1650) of a monetary economy in China, when political power and fiscal and economic resources were redistributed between the imperial court in Beijing and the provinces. Focusing on the area around the southeastern city of Suzhou, the book opens with a discussion of a widespread intellectual trend of close investigation of the observable world. It argues that artists constructed space and time with acute awareness of the embodied here and now and that they consciously reacted to and acted upon their surroundings. Going beyond the accepted historiographical understanding of Chinese painting in terms of an internal art-historical sequence arranged by stylistic changes, the book revises the common view of a “posthistorical” phase of Chinese art after the fourteenth century when, according to the traditional narrative, scholar artists developed a backward-looking and formalist art.

Designers and builders of the mid-Ming period created courtyards, gardens, and public sites by seeing or constructing place through pictorial conceits, and, through a concern for a sense of place, painters ardently correlated their pictorial themes with specific places in their actual surroundings. I argue that these intertwined processes of place-making and picture-making aligned the concept of “real scene” with an ecological aesthetic that acknowledged the visual and material clues and active forces of objects in spaces and afforded bodily and experiential engagement with the environment.

The reassessment of “real scene” practices forces a revision of the conventional view that Chinese ink painting was nonrealist and spontaneous. I argue instead that mid-Ming literati artists showed a determined pursuit of technical mastery and engagement in a prolonged process of skillful labor at their works. The sense of the “real” that their paintings evoke is the result of thoughtful composition and meticulous depiction of details, which create an effect of vividness and veracity. One of the innovators of “real scene” painting was Suzhou painter and scholar Wen Zhengming (1470–1559), a key figure in the book. Wen valued the process of arrangement and ordering (buzhi) as the primary criterion of creativity, and, with a critical grasp of past models, pursued in his paintings new models of composition that yielded images that were “real” to their audience in a novel way. Thus, Wen’s approach to painting led to the amalgamation of the “real” on two levels: familiarity of the subject and intelligibility of the composition. “Real scene” painting was practiced widely among Wen’s followers and students, as seen in Dao Hill Pavilion, by Qian Gu (1508–1587).

The approach my book develops deals with form in both abstract and concrete terms. The formal structures of paths and trees constitute pictorial spaces; arrangement and ordering of forms generate compositions. But these concrete pictorial forms also afford substantive hints as to how people organized real-life space, time, and community. I argue that artists’ emphasis on specific forms and details, their thoughtful compositions, and their extended painting process reflected their awareness of, and resistance to, the pace of daily life. I also argue that their paintings of familiar places were prompted by the impending transformation of their surroundings, as the Suzhou area was increasingly urbanized and becoming a commercial metropolis. The book looks at how the practice of painting defined place and self in a community within a changing social and physical environment.

The Real Scene: Painting, Life, and Place in China, 1450–1550
Lihong Liu, A. W. Mellon Postdoctoral Fellow, 2014–2016