Admission is always free Directions

Open today: 10:00 to 5:00

In Depth
Provenance Study: The Princely Collections of Liechtenstein

Nancy H. Yeide, Head of Curatorial Records and Files

2017 marks the 50th anniversary of the National Gallery of Art’s acquisition of its most famous painting: Ginevra de’ Benci by Leonardo da Vinci (fig. 1). Like most paintings in the collection, the story of this work’s journey to Washington is a fascinating one. In his memoir Self-Portrait with Donors: Confessions of an Art Collector (1969), John Walker, then director of the Gallery, describes his first encounter with Ginevra, owned since the early 18th century by the princes of Liechtenstein, at their castle in Vaduz (fig. 2):

"Other paintings were on exhibition in the museum the Prince of Liechtenstein had built in his capital, but Ginevra was too precious to be hung with the rest of the collection. . . . Finally in August 1960 . . ., guided by the prince’s curator, we went into the cellar where there was a trapdoor balanced by a huge counterweight. The trapdoor was lifted, and we descended more narrow stairs to a deep subcellar, where a few of the prince’s greatest treasures were stored. . . . There, on a nail, I saw Ginevra hanging."[1]

Walker made several more trips to Liechtenstein in hopes of obtaining the Leonardo for the Gallery, but it was not until early 1966 that the prince finally agreed to part with the painting. The reported $5 million price tag was the largest sum ever paid for a work of art until that time. [2] The small panel traveled to Washington in a suitcase in the first class section of a commercial airliner that was delayed by a snow storm in New York. Its public debut in Washington was on March 17, 1967, the 26th anniversary of the opening of the National Gallery of Art (fig. 3 and fig. 4).

return to top

The house of Liechtenstein, so dubbed because of the light stone (liechten stein, or limestone) of the castle at its original family seat near Vienna, achieved princely status in the early 17th century. Its territory was consolidated around the Duchy of Vaduz in the early 18th century, but the family continued to occupy its primary residence near Vienna until close to the outbreak of World War II, when it relocated to Vaduz. At that time the princely art collection, already of great renown, was moved as well. 

Although Prince Karl I (1569–1627) had begun to assemble paintings, jewels, metalwork, and objets d’art, the more influential early collector in the family was his son Prince Karl Eusebius (1611–1684), who devoted most of his time to the arts. It was Prince Karl Eusebius who acquired the first painting by Peter Paul RubensThe Assumption of the Virgin, for the collection, which to this day features a particularly strong holding of works by this artist. In 1693, Prince Karl Eusebius’s son, Prince Johann Adam Andreas I (1657–1712), acquired Rubens’s cycle of eight paintings depicting the life of the Roman consul Decius Mus, then believed to have been painted by Van Dyck. The cycle was originally created around 1617 as cartoons for tapestries that were produced in several editions. The National Gallery of Art owns a small oil sketch of the first work in the series, Decius Mus Addressing the Legions (fig. 5), that Rubens produced as a model for the life-size cartoons in Liechtenstein. 

Although paintings were regularly bought for and sold from the Princely Collections throughout the centuries, the reasons for these transactions are myriad, and didn’t always have to do with individual preference or changing tastes. By the end of World War II, the family had lost a large amount of its fortune. The art collection was one of the few remaining liquid assets that could be used to rebuild financial stability. The family made the difficult but necessary decision to sell Ginevra de' Benci and several other important paintings, including Rubens’s Agrippina and Germanicus (fig. 6) acquired in 1963 by the National Gallery of Art.

It is unclear when or how Ginevra de' Benci originally made its way into the house of Liechtenstein, but the work was a part of the collection by 1733, based on a red wax seal on the reverse (fig. 7). This same seal appears on the reverse of a pair of portraits by Joos von Cleve of Joris Vezeleer (fig. 8) and his wife, Margaretha Boghe (fig. 9), establishing these paintings as part of the Fideikomiss set up by Prince Johann Adam (1657–1712), which stipulated that the art collection and property in Vienna would belong to the reigning princes of the house of Liechtenstein in succession. In 1733 Prince Josef Wenzel (1696–1772)  applied red wax seals bearing the arms of Liechtenstein to all paintings that were part of the Fideikomissgalerie.

return to top

In addition to Ginevra de' Benci, the Rubenses, and the Joos von Cleve portraits, several other paintings and sculptures formerly in the Liechtenstein princely collection are now at the National Gallery of Art. The Lute Player by Orazio Gentileschi (fig. 10) was also included in the Fideikomissgalerie, as it had been acquired by the house of Liechtenstein in Bologna in 1697. However, there is no visible wax seal because the back of the painting was relined during conservation in the early 1960s.[3] A pair of genre scenes by Jean Siméon ChardinThe Attentive Nurse (fig. 11) and The Kitchen Maid (fig. 12), were acquired directly from the artist by Prince Josef Wenzel after the documentation of the Fideikomiss collection. Portrait of a Knight by Giovanni Girolamo Savoldo (fig. 13) had been acquired by 1659 by Archduke of Austria Leopold Wilhelm and descended into the collection of the Holy Roman emperors. By 1805, it had been traded to the Liechtenstein princely collection.  

Ginevra de' Benci is a rare example in which the princes sold directly to a museum without an intermediary. Zürich dealer Walter Feilchenfeldt handled many of the prints and drawings that left the princely collection, including those sold in 1948 to National Gallery of Art founding benefactor Lessing J. Rosenwald (fig. 14). First offered the enormous print collection, Rosenwald declined as there were too many duplicates of those he already owned. Feilchenfeldt then suggested that Rosenwald consider a few important drawings available from the princes. 

return to top

Rosenwald describes some of the drawings in his memoirs, Recollections of a Collector

“Among these there was an early silverpoint drawing of the death of the Virgin by an anonymous master (fig. 15); a pen-and-ink drawing of St. George (fig. 16) attributed to Hugo van der Goes; two watercolor landscapes by Augustin Hirsch Vogel (one of my favorite artists) (figs. 17 and 18); and two magnificent pen-and-ink drawings by Wolf Huber, the Annunciation to Joachim and a Danubian landscape (figs. 19 and 20).” [4]

All these drawings were donated in 1950 to the National Gallery of Art, where they remain today and can be viewed by appointment. The Death of the Virgin is one of the oldest works on paper in the entire collection. The two landscapes are, however, no longer believed to be by Hirsch Vogel. Paris and New York dealer Jacques Seligmann and Co., Inc. made several attempts to coax away some of the Liechtenstein holdings, finally succeeding in purchasing seven small marble 13th–14th-century sculptures in early 1953. Germain Seligman recalled in his Merchants of Art (1961):

“I had a vague recollection of having seen marbles in the Vienna Gallery years ago, but the only object I could recall with any clarity was a well-known bas-relief of a Madonna and Child (fig. 21), then attributed to Rossellino.”[5]

Eventually the firm was able to procure photographs of the Liechtenstein sculptures and, with the help of art historian Wilhelm Valentiner, produced a handsome volume publicizing the collection, which was sold later that year to the Samuel H. Kress Foundation. The sculptures were donated to the Gallery in 1960. In transferring ownership, the director of the Princely Collections wrote: “I wish to confirm to you that they formed a very important part of the collection of sculpture of His Highness, the Prince of Liechtenstein, and that until 1939 they were all on view in the Liechtenstein Palace in Vienna.”[6]

The collections of the princes of Liechtenstein have been regularly published and exhibited (see the bibliography at right). Today, portions of the Princely Collections can again be seen at the Garden Palace and the City Palace in Vienna.

return to top

Notes

[1] John Walker, Self-Portrait with Donors: Confessions of an Art Collector (Boston, 1974), 49–50.

[2] Click here for a copy of the 1967 press release (PDF 2.4 MB). 

[3] See Technical Summary for The Lute Player, http://www.nga.gov/content/ngaweb/Collection/art-object-page.46434.html#consvNotes

[4] Lessing J. Rosenwald and Edith Goodkind Rosenwald, Recollections of a Collector (Jenkintown, PA, 1976), 47, https://library.nga.gov/help/40221_rosenwald_recollections_small.pdf

[5] Germain Seligman, Merchants of Art: 1880–1960; Eighty Years of Professional Collecting (New York, 1961), 256. Germain, the son of Jacques Seligmann, changed his name when he became an American citizen.

[6] Jacques Seligmann & Co., Inc., Franz Josef, William Reinhold Valentiner, and Germain Seligmann, A Catalogue of Seven Marble Sculptures of the Italian Trecento and Quattrocento from the Collection of His Highness, The Prince of Liechtenstein (New York, 1954): PDF (5.3 MB) available here.

return to top

Citation

To Cite: Nancy H. Yeide,  "The Princely Collections of Liechtenstein," National Gallery of Art, last modified December 12, 2016, www.nga.gov/research/in-depth/provenance-study-princely-collections-liechtenstein.html

Bibliography

The Princely Collections of Liechtenstein

1943
Strohmer, Erich V. Die Gemäldegalerie des Fürsten Liechtenstein in Wien. Wien 1943.

1948
Meisterwerke aus den Sammlungen des Fürsten von Liechtenstein: Die niederländischen Bilder in der Liechtenstein Galerie. Exh. cat. Kunstmuseum, Lucerne; Baldass, Ludwig. Lucerne 1948.

1954
Seligmann, Jacques, & Fils, Franz Josef, William Reinhold Valentiner, and Germain Seligmann. A Catalogue of Seven Marble Sculptures of the Italian Trecento and Quattrocento from the Collection of his Highness the Prince of Liechtenstein. New York, 1954. (PDF 5.3 MB)

1980
Baumstark, Reinhold. Masterpieces from the Collection of the Princes of Liechtenstein. New York, 1980.

1995
Collections du Prince de Liechtenstein. Exh. cat. Musée national d'histoire et d'art, Luxembourg, 1995.

2004
Kräfter, Johann, Wilfried Seipel, and Renate Trnek. Rubens in Vienna. The Masterpieces. Vienna, 2004.

2013
Kräftner, Johan. Die Schätze der Liechtenstein: Paläste, Gemälde, Skulpturen. Vienna, 2013.