A pair of portraits of Emilia di Spilimbergo and her younger sister Irene was begun in about 1558, most likely in anticipation of their prospective marriages. The initial reason may have been to present two highly eligible, aristocratic young women to potential husbands, or the portraits may have been intended as permanent mementos for the sisters’ family after they were married. In either case, the rationale shifted when Irene died tragically the following year.
Too little information exists about Emilia’s biography to know for certain why the seascape to the right shows a storm-tossed ship, but since the two portraits were almost certainly painted contemporaneously, the motif probably alludes to the turbulent state of her emotions after the loss of her sister.
A few months after Irene’s death, the sisters’ grandfather, the wealthy Venetian citizen Zuan Paolo da Ponte, noted in his journal that he was dissatisfied with a portrait of Irene—and presumably also one of Emilia—that had been begun two years previously by Gian Paolo Pace. The patron asked Titian, who years earlier had painted Zuan Paolo’s own portrait and that of Giulia, the sisters’ mother, to complete it. However, at that stage of his career, Titian himself would have been devoting his best efforts almost exclusively to King Philip II of Spain. The master would have likely delegated a request of this kind to one of the assistants in his workshop.
The portraits of the sisters Emilia and
Fabio di Maniago, Storia della belle arti friulane (Udine, 1819), frontispiece. See Caterina Furlan, “Tiziano nella storiografia artistica friulana tra Sette e Ottocento,” Studi Tizianeschi 3 (2005): 92–95.
Emilia (1536–1585) and her younger sister Irene (1538–1559) were the daughters of the Friulian nobleman Adriano di Spilimbergo and Giulia, daughter of the wealthy Venetian citizen Zuan Paolo da Ponte. According to Giorgio Vasari, Titian painted the portraits of the members of three generations of the family: “Among the portraits by Titian is one . . . of Paolo da Ponte, whose beautiful young daughter Giulia (who was a confidante of his) Titian also portrayed, as he did the lovely Signora Irene, a young woman well versed in literature and music who was studying design. When she died about seven years ago she was honoured by nearly every Italian writer.”
Giorgio Vasari, The Lives of the Artists: A Selection, trans. George Bull (Harmondsworth, 1965), 459–460; Giorgio Vasari, Le vite de’ più eccellenti pittori, scultori e architettori, ed. Rosanna Bettarini and Paola Barocchi (Florence, 1987), 6:167–168: “La signora Irene, vergine bellissima, letterata, musica et incaminata nel disegno, la quale, morendo circa sette anni sono, fu celebrata quasi da tutte le penne degli scrittori d’Italia.”
See Tiziano ritrovato: Il ritratto di messer Zuan Paulo da Ponte (Venice, 1998). The portrait of Zuan Paolo, which in 1998 was with the dealer Pietro Scarpa in Venice, carries the inscription on the reverse: +ZAN PAULO DA PONTE+/ SPILINBERGO. The picture appears to be in poor condition but authentic. Zuan Paolo’s Memoriale is reputedly in a private collection in Venice and is not easily accessible.
Dionigi Atanagi, Rime di diversi nobilissimi et eccellentissimi autori in morte della Signora Irene delle Signore di Spilimbergo (Venice, 1561).
Atanagi’s biography of Irene, together with further modern research, provides considerable information about her personality and accomplishments.
Dionigi Atanagi, Rime di diversi nobilissimi et eccellentissimi autori in morte della Signora Irene delle Signore di Spilimbergo (Venice, 1561), under “Vita della Signora Irene,” unpaginated; see also Ruggero Zotti, Irene di Spilimbergo (Udine, 1914), 22–28. A useful recent biographical sketch of Irene is provided by Anne Jacobsen Schutte, “Irene di Spilimbergo: The Image of a Creative Woman in Late Renaissance Italy,” Renaissance Quarterly 44 (1991): 42–61.
Dionigi Atanagi, Rime di diversi nobilissimi et eccellentissimi autori in morte della Signora Irene delle Signore di Spilimbergo (Venice, 1561), 114, 146, 165; Anton Maria Amadi, Ragionamento di M. Anton Maria Amadi: Intorno a quel sonetto del Petrarca . . . (Padua, 1563). For Emilia’s marriage see Anne Jacobsen Schutte, “Irene di Spilimbergo: The Image of a Creative Woman in Late Renaissance Italy,” Renaissance Quarterly 44 (1991): 44.
On June 28, 1560, a few months after Irene’s death the previous December, her grandfather noted in his Memoriale that a portrait of her—and presumably also one of her sister—had been begun two years previously by Gian Paolo Pace, but that this painter had sketched it so poorly that the patron asked Titian to complete it.
The first passage, dated June 28, 1560, reads as follows: “Mandai a messer Tutian per l’opera per lui fata nel retrato della nostra già benedetta memoria d’Irene abozata assai malamaente da Ser Zuan Paulo de Pase et lassata imperfetta per dui anni si che rimase ben che la poverina andò a miglior vita. Ma Messer Tutian per sua gratia si tolse il cargo de volerlo finir et conzata talmente che si può dir per certo che se fusse sta presente meglio non si poteva desiderar. Gli mandai ducati 6 viniciani et per sua cortesia se a contenta che mertia assai più” (I sent for Messer Titian to undertake the work he did on the portrait of our Irene of blessed memory. This had been begun very badly by Gian Paolo Pace two years before the poor girl went to a better life, but was left unfinished by him. But Messer Titian graciously assumed the burden of completing it, making her appear as if really present, in a way that was better than one could possibly have hoped for. I sent him six Venetian ducats, which he courteously accepted, although his work was worth much more). The second passage reads: “Il qual M. Tutian per haver nella mente la sua effigie l’a finita e fata si che se l’havesse avuto presente non l’haveria potuto far meglio” (Titian had retained her likeness in his mind, and when finishing her portrait he made her appear as if present, in a way that could scarcely be bettered). See Ferruccio Carreri, “Report in La Difesa, 17–18 August 1911,” L’arte 14 (1911): 394, repro.; Michelangelo Muraro, “Il memoriale de Zuan Paolo da Ponte,” Archivio veneto 79 (1949): 83.
Elsje van Kessel, The Lives of Paintings: Presence, Agency and Likeness in Venetian Art of the Sixteenth Century (Berlin, 2017), 145.
Elsje van Kessel, The Lives of Paintings: Presence, Agency and Likeness in Venetian Art of the Sixteenth Century (Berlin, 2017), 137, 146–150.
Fabio di Maniago, Storia della belle arti friulane (Udine, 1819), 88–90.
The traditional attribution of the portraits to Titian, based on the account of Vasari, and also on the very similar one by Carlo Ridolfi, was still unchallenged at the beginning of the 20th century.
For Vasari, see Entry note 2; Carlo Ridolfi, Le maraviglie dell’arte, overo Le vite de gl’illustri pittori veneti, e dello stato, ed. Detlev von Hadeln (Berlin, 1914), 1:194.
Joseph Archer Crowe and Giovanni Battista Cavalcaselle, Titian, His Life and Times (London, 1877), 2:301–303.
For these events, see Corrado Ricci, “Ritratti ‘tizianeschi’ di Gian Paolo Pace,” Rivista del R. Istituto d’Archeologia e Storia dell’Arte 7 (1929): 257–258. The rejection of the traditional attribution to Titian is recorded by Oscar Ulm, “I ritratti d’Irene ed Emilia di Spilimbergo erroneamente attribuiti a Tiziano,” Emporium 31 (1910): 126–135.
Michelangelo Muraro, “Il memoriale de Zuan Paolo da Ponte,” Archivio veneto 79 (1949): 82–84. See also Hans Tietze and Erica Tietze-Conrat, “I ritratti Spilimbergo a Washington,” Emporium 67 (1953): 99–107.
In the absence of the original document, it is difficult to assess the reliability or otherwise of the passages published by Carreri; yet it seems likely that even if they were tampered with, they were not, after all, complete fabrications. It is true that in terms of their aesthetic quality neither of the Spilimbergo portraits can be accepted as the work of Titian, even in part; and although a case has sometimes been made for seeing the Irene as superior to the Emilia—for instance by the Tietzes, Harold Wethey, and Fern Rusk Shapley
Hans Tietze and Erica Tietze-Conrat, “I ritratti Spilimbergo a Washington,” Emporium 67 (1953): 99–107; Harold Wethey, The Paintings of Titian (London, 1971), 2:178, 198; and Fern Rusk Shapley, Catalogue of the Italian Paintings (Washington, DC, 1979), 1:500–503.
Whether or not this assistant was Gian Paolo Pace is another matter. Again, the mention in the Memoriale that he was responsible for making a start at least on the portrait of Irene may be regarded as reliable, since no unscrupulous historian or dealer would have had any interest in inventing a story about a painter who was almost entirely obscure. Since 1911 Pace has, in fact, been widely accepted as the author of the portraits, in whole or in part, including by Corrado Ricci, the Tietzes, Ettore Camesasca, Wethey, and Giorgio Tagliaferro.
Corrado Ricci, “Ritratti ‘tizianeschi’ di Gian Paolo Pace,” Rivista del R. Istituto d’Archeologia e Storia dell’Arte 7 (1929): 257; Hans Tietze and Erica Tietze-Conrat, “I ritratti Spilimbergo a Washington,” Emporium 67 (1953): 99–107; Ettore Camesasca, ed., Lettere sull’arte di Pietro Aretino, comm. Fidenzio Pertile (Milan, 1960), 3:397; Harold Wethey, The Paintings of Titian (London, 1971), 2:178, 198; Giorgio Tagliaferro in Le botteghe di Tiziano (Florence, 2009), 168–172. Shapley, however, suspicious of Carreri’s document, rejected the attribution to Pace, and gave the picture to an anonymous follower of Titian. Berenson retained the attribution to Titian he had adopted in 1894, 1916, and 1932. See Fern Rusk Shapley, Catalogue of the Italian Paintings (Washington, DC, 1979), 1:500–503; and Bernard Berenson, Italian Pictures of the Renaissance: Venetian School (London, 1957), 1:192.
Mattia Biffis, “Di Zuan Paolo Pace, chierico e laico,” Studi Tizianeschi 7 (2012): 55–56, 64.
Sometimes associated with the pair is a stylistically and compositionally similar Portrait of a Woman, formerly in the Quincy Shaw collection, Boston, and the Peterkin collection, Andover, Massachusetts. Since it is smaller than the pair (72 × 48 cm), Lionello Venturi suggested that it was Titian’s autograph modello for the Irene.
As reported by Hans Tietze and Erica Tietze-Conrat, “I ritratti Spilimbergo a Washington,” Emporium 67 (1953): 104.
Hans Tietze and Erica Tietze-Conrat, “I ritratti Spilimbergo a Washington,” Emporium 67 (1953): 99–107.
Francesco Valcanover, L’opera completa di Tiziano (Milan, 1969), 138, no. 583.
Joseph Archer Crowe and Giovanni Battista Cavalcaselle, Titian, His Life and Times (London, 1877), 2:303.
Linda Borean, “Il carteggio di Abraham Hume e Giovanni Maria Sasso,” in Il collezionismo a Venezia e nel Veneto ai tempi della Serenissima, ed. Bernard Aikema, Rosella Lauber, and Max Seidel (Venice, 2005), 328.
March 21, 2019
Commissioned by the Spilimbergo family, Spilimbergo, Italy; by inheritance to Count Giulio di Spilimbergo, Domanins, by 1819; by inheritance to Count Niccolò d'Attimis Maniago, Florence, by 1904; and Count Enrico d'Attimis Maniago, Florence until 1909; Elia Volpi [1858-1938], Florence; sold 1909 to (Duveen Brothers, Inc., London and New York); sold October 1909 to Peter A.B. Widener [1834-1915], Elkins Park, Pennsylvania; Inheritance from the Estate of Peter A.B. Widener by gift through power of appointment of Joseph E. Widener, Elkins Park.
The painting was executed on a medium-weight twill-weave fabric, which was prepared with a white ground, followed by a thin dark-brown imprimatura layer. The artist applied the paint wet-into-wet, often using a well-laden brush to produce impasto. The x-radiographs
The support was lined and the tacking margins were removed, and although cusping is apparent only on the top and bottom edges, there is no indication that the painting has been reduced in size. The paint is now in poor condition, with the impasto disrupted by the cupped and crushed surface, and it is covered with thick yellowed varnish and copious overpaint. The awkward position of the sitter’s eyes is explained by the fact that little of the left eye is original, and the mouth has also been altered by retouching.
Joanna Dunn and Peter Humfrey based on the examination reports by William Leisher, Susanna Griswold, and Joanna Dunn
March 21, 2019
- Di Maniago, Fabio. Storia della Belle Arti Friulane. Udine, 1819: 88-90.
- Hume, Abraham. Notices of the Life and Works of Titian. London, 1829: 47.
- Carrer, Luigi. Anello di Sette Gemme. Venice, 1838: 695.
- Crowe, Joseph Archer, and Giovanni Battista Cavalcaselle. Titian, His Life and Times. 2 vols. London, 1877: 2:301-303.
- Berenson, Bernard. The Venetian Painters of the Renaissance. New York and London, 1894: 143.
- Gronau, Georg. Tizian. Berlin, 1900: 168-169.
- Venturi, Adolfo. Storia dell’arte italiana. 11 vols. Milan, 1901-1940: 9, part 3(1928):167.
- Fischel, Oskar. Tizian: Des Meisters Gemälde. Stuttgart [u.a.], 1904: 195.
- Reinach, Salomon. Répertoire de peintures du moyen âge et de la Renaissance (1280-1580). 6 vols. Paris, 1905-1923: 6(1923):76.
- Gronau, Georg. “Gian Paolo Pace.” In Allgemeines Lexikon der bildenden Künstler von der Antike bis zur Gegenwart. Edited by Ulrich Thieme and Felix Becker. 37 vols. Leipzig, 1907-1950: 26(1932):117.
- Ulm, Oscar. “I ritratti d'Irene ed Emilia di Spilimbergo erroneamente attribuiti a Tiziano.” Emporium 31 (1910): 126-135.
- Carreri, Ferruccio. "Report in La Difesa, 17–18 August 1911." Reproduced in L’Arte 14 (1911): 394.
- Ridolfi, Carlo. Le maraviglie dell’arte, overo Le vite de gl'illustri pittori veneti, e dello Stato (Venice, 1648). Edited by Detlev von Hadeln. 2 vols. Berlin, 1914-1924: 1(1914):194.
- Berenson, Bernard, and William Roberts. Pictures in the Collection of P.A.B. Widener at Lynnewood Hall, Elkins Park, Pennsylvania: Early Italian and Spanish Schools. Philadelphia, 1916: unpaginated, repro., as by Titian.
- Paintings in the Collection of Joseph Widener at Lynnewood Hall. Intro. by Wilhelm R. Valentiner. Elkins Park, Pennsylvania, 1923: unpaginated, repro.
- Fischel, Oskar. Tizian: Des Meisters Gemälde. 5th ed. Stuttgart, 1924: 208-209.
- Molmenti, Pompeo. La storia di Venezia nella vita privata dalle origini alla caduta della Repubblica. 3 vols. Bergamo, 1926–1928: 2(1928):122, 249, 275, 373-374.
- Ricci, Corrado. “Ritratti ‘tizianeschi’ di Gian Paolo Pace.” Rivista del R. Istituto d’Archeologia e Storia dell’Arte 7 (1929): 257-258.
- Paintings in the Collection of Joseph Widener at Lynnewood Hall. Intro. by Wilhelm R. Valentiner. Elkins Park, Pennsylvania, 1931: 110, repro., as by Titian.
- Berenson, Bernard. Italian Pictures of the Renaissance: A List of the Principal Artists and Their Works with an Index of Places. Oxford, 1932: 574.
- Waldmann, Emil. “Die Sammlung Widener.” Pantheon 21–22 (1938): 340.
- Duveen Brothers. Duveen Pictures in Public Collections of America. New York, 1941: no. 161, repro., as by Titian.
- Works of Art from the Widener Collection. Foreword by David Finley and John Walker. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1942: 7, as by Titian.
- Paintings and Sculpture from the Widener Collection. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1948 (reprinted 1959): 24, repro., as by Titian.
- Muraro, Michelangelo. “Il memoriale de Zuan Paolo da Ponte.” Archivio Veneto 79 (1949): 82-84.
- Tietze, Hans, and Erica Tietze-Conrat. “I ritratti Spilimbergo a Washington.” Emporium 67 (1953): 99-107.
- Berenson, Bernard. Italian Pictures of the Renaissance. Venetian School. 2 vols. London, 1957: 1:192.
- Camesasca, Ettore, ed. Lettere sull’Arte di Pietro Aretino. Commentate da Fidenzio Pertile. 3 vols. Milan, 1957-1960: 3(1960):397.
- Valcanover, Francesco. Tutta la pittura di Tiziano. 2 vols. Milan, 1960: 2:70.
- Summary Catalogue of European Paintings and Sculpture. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1965: 130.
- National Gallery of Art. European Paintings and Sculpture, Illustrations. Washington, 1968: 117, repro.
- Pallucchini, Rodolfo. Tiziano. 2 vols. Florence, 1969: 1:221.
- Valcanover, Francesco. L’opera completa di Tiziano. Milan, 1969: 141, no. 632.
- Wethey, Harold. The Paintings of Titian. 3 vols. London, 1969-1975: 2(1971):178, 198.
- Fredericksen, Burton B., and Federico Zeri. Census of Pre-Nineteenth Century Italian Paintings in North American Public Collections. Cambridge, Mass., 1972: 203, 517, 646.
- European Paintings: An Illustrated Summary Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1975: 344, repro.
- Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. New York, 1975: 211, no. 262, color repro.
- Shapley, Fern Rusk. Catalogue of the Italian Paintings. 2 vols. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1979: 1:500-503; 2:pl. 351.
- Heinemann, Fritz. “La bottega di Tiziano.” In Tiziano e Venezia: convegno internazionale di studi (1976). Vicenza, 1980: 438.
- Walker, John. National Gallery of Art, Washington. Rev. ed. New York, 1984: 210, no. 256, colorr repro.
- European Paintings: An Illustrated Catalogue. National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1985: 399, repro.
- Kopper, Philip. America's National Gallery of Art: A Gift to the Nation. New York, 1991: 193, repro.
- Schutte, Anne Jacobsen. “Irene di Spilimbergo: The Image of a Creative Woman in Late Renaissance Italy.” Renaissance Quarterly 44 (1991): 44.
- Ferrazza, Roberta. Palazzo Davanzati e le collezioni di Elia Volpi. Florence, 1993: 101 fig. 95, 104-105, 137-138 nn. 81-86, 196 fig. 198.
- Lloyd, Christopher. Italian Paintings before 1600 in the Art Institute of Chicago. Princeton, 1993: 248.
- King, Catherine. “Looking a Sight: Sixteenth-Century Portraits of Woman Artists.” Zeitschrift für Kunstgeschichte 58 (1995): 391.
- Burke, Peter. “Il ritratto veneziano del Cinquecento.” In Pittura nel Veneto. Il Cinquecento. Edited by Mauro Lucco. 3 vols. Milan, 1996-1999: 3(1999):1108.
- Pedrocco, Filippo. Titian: The Complete Paintings. New York, 2001: 31.
- Borean, Linda. “Il carteggio di Abraham Hume e Giovanni Maria Sasso.” In Il Collezionismo a Venezia e nel Veneto ai Tempi della Serenissima. Edited by Bernard Aikema, Rosella Lauber and Max Seidel. Venice, 2005: 338.
- Furlan, Caterina. “Tiziano nella storiografia artistica friulana tra Sette e Ottocento.” Studi Tizianeschi 3 (2005): 92-95.
- Dal Pozzolo, Enrico Maria. “La ‘bottega’ di Tiziano: sistema solare e buco nero.” Studi Tizianeschi 4 (2006): 80.
- Tagliaferro, Giorgio, and Bernard Aikema, with Matteo Mancini and Andrew John. Le botteghe di Tiziano. Florence, 2009: 61-62, 121, 160, 168-172, 201.
- Biffis, Mattia. “Di Zuan Paolo Pace, chierico e laico”. Studi Tizianeschi 7 (2012): 55-56, 64.
- Hale, Sheila. Titian: His Life. London, 2012: 585.
- Van Kessel, Elsje. The Lives of Paintings: Presence, Agency and Likeness in Venetian Art of the Sixteenth Century. Berlin, 2017: 131-179.