Article

In Plain Sight: What to Do When You Don’t “Get” Modern Art

By
  • Tamar Avishai
4 min read

Modern art. Is there anything else that can strike so much fear in the heart of the average museumgoer?

Canvases are spattered with paint, lined with grids, or barely contain shapes that seem to want to float away. Faces or buildings or trees emerge from a geometric background, but on close inspection, they break apart into brushstrokes. A car tire is cut apart and reassembled. A giant mobile floats in the air, catching the breeze. The whole world is shaded blue. Is it any wonder that, compared to the straightforward, legible works of, say, the Renaissance, this could feel destabilizing?

When it comes to modern art, it’s natural to ask, well, what does it mean? What is this work about? How did we just go from fauvism to cubism to futurism? How could I ever understand this stuff without a graduate degree?

But you can! I promise you, you can. Because modern art is all about being of its own moment—which means that we can feel free to relate it to our moment. “We’re dealing with some of the same issues about how we put the world together,” says Harry Cooper, Bunny Mellon Curator of Modern Art at the National Gallery. “I could sit down with Cezanne and have a conversation that wouldn’t feel so alien.”

We look down onto nine pieces of fruit, a pitcher, a goblet, and a dish arranged on a rustic wood table in front of a floral curtain in this nearly square, loosely painted still life. The table extends off the left edge of the composition and the back, right corner of the table just touches the right edge of the canvas. At the center of the composition, five pieces of marigold-orange fruit with yellow highlights and scarlet-red shading are piled in the dish. The side of the dish to our right is slightly tipped up so the fruit settles near the rim to our left. The dish is painted with loose strokes of sky blue, shell pink, pale yellow, and parchment white. Three more pieces of fruit, including a lemon, sit to our left of the dish and one more piece of fruit sits near the back corner of the table, behind the dish, to our right. Immediately behind the dish is a stemmed glass with a tall, rounded bowl. To our left, between the fruit on the table and in the platter, is a tall, angular, tapering pitcher. The pitcher is painted with emerald and moss-green leaves against a background painted with strokes of light peach, blush pink, slate blue, and one wide stroke of amber orange. The wooden table is peanut brown streaked with strokes of apricot orange and pale sage green. One drawer at the front has a round, wooden pull. There seem to be at least two panels of curtains hanging behind the table. Down the center of the background is a panel of coral peach and saffron orange with a floral pattern painted in wheat brown and denim blue. To our right, the panel is streaked with vertical strokes of teal, midnight, and navy blue. The area to our left, behind the table, could be the panel of a door, painted with pale turquoise. The fruit, dish, vessels, table, curtain, and door are all outlined with cobalt blue.
Paul Cezanne, Still Life with Milk Jug and Fruit, c. 1900, oil on canvas, Gift of the W. Averell Harriman Foundation in memory of Marie N. Harriman, 1972.9.5

And it’s true. We can recognize from Cezanne’s work just how relatable and human he was, how similar to us. This is what modern art is all about: human beings painting the modern world, life as it is being lived. Not life separated from us by allegory, mythology, or biblical narrative, but the real, gritty, actual world. And if an artist is so present in their world, we can connect with it as well. “I definitely feel drawn to [works] that evoke some emotion in me,” said Jade Rosser, a visitor. “You can feel the temperature in the colors, the different emotions the artist felt. It makes me feel that way too.”

Thumbnail image for In Plain Sight podcast series, the podcast title inside the iris of a stylized eye icon and National Gallery of Art and The Lonely Palette logos below

This episode, the last of our series, explores art that may not always make sense to our eyes but can still speak to our souls. Because so much of modern art is abstract. Or at the very least, it’s nonrepresentational: it doesn’t necessarily depict a concrete thing.

Modern art invites our interpretations. It actually thrives on them. We are all full of abstract feelings, so we can relate to these paintings more than we might think. Sometimes it can feel like seeing objects in clouds. Sometimes it can feel like a Rorschach test. Sometimes you can see something that you know the artist didn’t intend, but whatever. It’s okay. You looked closely, and you saw what you saw.

So find the images in the clouds. Bring your own experiences and figure out what a work reminds you of. It’s so much easier, after that, after the spark is lit, to absorb art historical information. To understand the artist’s context and intentions. To sit down with Cezanne and smell the fresh, drying paint, and realize how much we share.

Episode Highlights

Painted entirely in shades of blue, this vertical scene shows a woman, an elderly man, and a young child standing close to each other near the edge of gently lapping waves. All three people have gray complexions tinged with blue, are barefoot, and their features, clothing, and bodies are outlined. To our left, the woman’s back is to us, and her face is turned in profile to our right as she looks down at the ground. Her navy-blue, nearly black hair is pulled up in a loose bun. She wears a deep ocean-blue shawl over a long skirt that covers her entire body except for bare toes peeking out under the hem. The form of the shawl protrudes a bit on the right as if she holds her arm across her body. The slightly taller man stands across from her to our right with his body mirroring the woman’s. He crosses his arms tightly across his chest as he gazes down in profile. The eye we can see is deeply shadowed, and his hands are tucked into his elbows. He has a beard and short, dark hair with streaks of sky blue. His long, marine-blue shirt blends into his pants, which are cut off at the ankles. Unlike the woman, he stands with the weight on one foot, the other knee bent. To our right and in front of the man, the child stands facing our left in profile. He has short, dark hair, and he looks toward the woman. He touches or gestures near the man’s thigh with his right hand, farther from us, and holds his other out in front of his waist. His shawl has a reddish tint, which contrasts with his ankle-length, stone-blue pants. The trio stands on aquamarine-tinted sand before gentle waves along a shoreline. In the top third of painting, the sky is a block of celestial blue. The artist signed his name, “Picasso,” in a dark blue in the lower right corner and dated the painting, “1903” in the upper right.
Pablo Picasso, The Tragedy, 1903, oil on wood, Chester Dale Collection, 1963.10.196

“It's a very cold painting. You can kind of feel the temperature of it. I like piece’s that make me feel that way. The great sadness in this just speaks very loudly to me.”

– Jade Rosser, Visitor

Christopher Wool, Untitled, 2017, bronze, copper-plated stainless steel, and stainless steel, Gift of Christopher Wool in memory of Dr. Glorye Wool and Dr. Ira Wool and the Patrons' Permanent Fund, 2021.12.1

“The artist was inspired by his time in Texas and seeing after a tornado the tangles of wire. This one little girl last summer who heard her talking with her mother, and she said, this looks like a bowl of spaghetti. I just love that. We light the spark, we don't fill the bucket.” 

– Brett McNish, Grounds Manager

“The last time I was here, one of the guards came to me and said, ‘I've worked here for two years, and I don't understand why what anybody sees when they look at Rothkos.’ And I said, ‘Do you go to church?’ And he said yeah. I said, ‘Well, how do you feel when you're singing in the choir and all the music blends together and you just go someplace? That's how I feel when I see them.’ He nodded, because he knew that feeling of giving yourself over to something.”

– Claire Rosser, Visitor

You may also like

A parent and child look at Edgar Degas's The Riders together

Article:  In Plain Sight: Finding Your First (Art) Love

How can we learn to fall in love with a work of art? From curators who share the works that sparked their lifelong passion for art.

Wendy MacNaughton's watercolor and ink illustration of Kerry James Marshall

Article:  Exquisite Corpse with Kerry James Marshall (and friends!)

The history painter takes inspiration from an old surrealist game — and so can we, as an opportunity for connection.