Admission is always free Directions

Open today: 10:00 to 5:00

Striking the Right Chord: Seeing Music in Dutch Genre Painting

 
 

Cut-and-paste citation text:

Jennifer Henel / https://purl.org/nga/documents/literature/essays/striking-the-right-chord-seeing-music-in-dutch-genre-painting (accessed Dec 11, 2017).

 

Export as PDF


Export from an essay page includes title, essay sections, images, comparable figures and notes.

PDF  
 
Version Link

You may download complete editions of this catalog from the catalog’s home page.

To judge from the elegant worlds pictured by Johannes Vermeer and his contemporaries, music and music making were a mainstay of upper-class Dutch life. Theorboes, lutes, clavichords, and bass violas permeate scenes of courtship, love, and leisure, filling these scenes of so-called everyday life with a soundtrack all their own.[1] In Jan Steen’s Young Woman Playing a Harpsichord to a Young Man, for example, a woman’s fingers rest gently on a harpsichord’s keys as she gazes at the music before her, its notes registered for the bass and treble clef [fig. 1]. Her parted lips suggest she might be singing while the well-dressed gentleman leaning nonchalantly on her instrument gazes down at her. In the background, a page brings a theorbo-lute so that the gentleman can join her in a duet. Across the upper panel of the harpsichord, the inscribed words Acta Virum Probant (actions prove the man) underscore that the harmony the woman and man create comes as much from love as their playing.[2] 

The ability of painting to convey music and sound was not limited, however, to the subjects they represented. Line, shape, and color, too, were central to a composition’s sense of harmony. When, in 1604, the Dutch theorist Karel van Mander published his Het Schilder-boek (The painting book), a manual for artists, he likened musical composition to the need for balance in a painted work: “Just as in music the multifarious sounds of the singers and the players harmonize, so here too [in painting] do the many different figures.”[3] Harmony, his dictum suggests, is found in the mechanics—or color and shape—of the composition, not just in the image itself.

For many in the 17th century, the question of balance was not only visual, it was also aural. Indeed, during that time there was an awareness of and interest in a concept later named synesthesia, from the Greek syn (union) and aísthesis (sensation), meaning the union of the senses.[4] Since the 4th century BC, theorists and philosophers, including Aristotle, have explored the link between color and sound, investigating the relationship between chromatic and musical tones.[5] 

kircher-colorchart_1646

Fig. 2 - Athanasius Kircher, Color chart, 1646,
adapted by the author

These concepts were recognized and refined over the centuries by numerous scholars, including the 17th-century German Jesuit priest Athanasius Kircher, who, among other topics, wrote extensively on music theory.[6] One of Kircher’s most important theories was his work on the correspondence of musical notes to specific colors, which he coded into a chart and published in 1646 (for an adaptation of this chart, see [fig. 2] at right). According to Kircher, deep, dark sounds of minor notes are associated with cool, deep colors, while the warmer, brighter sounds of major notes are warmer, lighter colors. As a Jesuit priest, Kircher believed that the coexistence of sensory functions had profound implications in worship and that the immersion of sight and sound had the capacity, as one scholar wrote, to “move the passions, to produce strong emotional effects that, under properly controlled conditions, [could] ravish the soul and lead the faithful closer to the divine.”[7] 

Kircher’s articulation of the multisensory relationship between color and music resonates with Van Mander’s advice for artists and suggests that the experience of looking at painting may engage viewers on a variety of sensory levels. For synesthetes, the integration of certain colors and shapes on an artist’s panel or canvas may stimulate a musical experience, which would allow them to “hear” the painting.

For most viewers, a painting’s composition reinforces the subject matter. In Vermeer’s Woman with a Lute, for example, which is largely a cool, dark painting, accents of warm light on the upper left of the wall (promoted by whites and creams) direct our attention to the woman’s face [fig. 3]. Viewers are drawn in by the painting’s composition and color, while the lady tuning the lute provides the aural suggestion of harmony and balance.

A synesthete, however, might engage with this painting in a different way. The cool, dark tones present in the foreground could elicit a deep pitch, while the brighter colors on the back wall and in the face of the subject might produce warmer, major chords. Shapes also create aural associations: the diagonals of the tablecloth’s edge and the curtain’s shadow paired with the gently curving circles and ovals of the lute and the woman’s face might create similar aural associations, perhaps sharp notes accompanied by a gentle major resolve (the movement from a dissonant sound to a consonant sound). Most synesthetes scan the progression of a painting like a musical score: from top to bottom, left to right.[8] Here the work might open with a major chord in the far upper left, with the yellow from the daylight. Then, as the eye moves down through the diffused light of the wall to the darker registers, minor chords sound. The cool white of the elegant ermine trim on the woman’s jacket could be a diminished chord, with the major resolve seen in the cream-and-gray marbled tile in the lower right.[9] 

Paintings need not depict music to convey musicality, as evident in even the quietest of scenes, such as Vermeer’s Woman Holding a Balance [fig. 4]. While the subject matter and palette of this sublime painting imbue a sense of silence, a synesthete might hear major chords in the warm tones of the uppermost left, minor chords repeated in the rhythmic folds of dark blue cloth, an end refrain in the diagonal of the lady’s arm, and a major resolve in the narrow, vertical strip of the warm, creamy wall.

The visual harmony created by these Dutch artists transcends their subjects and creates a transformative experience that entwines the senses as one looks and listens to a work.

**For further information on this topic, please join the author for her lecture Striking the Right Chord: Seeing Music in Dutch Genre Painting at the National Gallery of Art on December 5 at 2:00 p.m. in the West Building Lecture Hall.

  Jennifer Henel

  Fri Oct 27 00:00:00 EDT 2017

Figures


Comparable Figure
[fig. 1] Jan Steen, Young Woman Playing a Harpischord to a Young Man, c. 1659, oil on panel, The National Gallery, London. Bought, 1871. © The National Gallery, London
Compare Image


Comparable Figure
[fig. 2] Athanasius Kircher, Color chart, 1646. adapted by the author


Comparable Figure
[fig. 3] Johannes Vermeer, A Woman with a Lute, c. 1663–1664, oil on canvas, The Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, Bequest of Collis P. Huntington, 1900, 25.110.24. © 2017 The Metropolitan Museum of Art/Art Resource/Scala, Florence
Compare Image


Comparable Figure
[fig. 4] Johannes Vermeer, Woman Holding a Balance, c. 1664, oil on canvas, National Gallery of Art, Washington, Widener Collection, 1942.9.97
Compare Image


Notes

  1. I would like to thank Arthur Wheelock and Alexandra Libby for their thoughtful comments on this essay.

  2. This painting’s theme echoes a sentiment expressed in the emblem “Who does not feel love?” (Quid non sentit amor?), found in Jacob Cats’s celebrated book of emblems Sinne- en minnebeelden (1618). Above this emblem is the adage “A man tunes two lutes: as he tunes one, the strings of the other begin to vibrate in unison, suggesting lovers’ hearts beating in tandem.” Marjorie Wieseman, Vermeer and Music: The Art of Love and Leisure (The National Gallery, London, 2013), 26.

  3. Paraphrased and translated from Karel van Mander’s Het Schilder-boek in Marjorie Wieseman, Vermeer and Music: The Art of Love and Leisure (The National Gallery, London, 2013), 10.

  4. From Sean A. Day, “Synesthesia,” http://www.daysyn.com/Definition.html. Though this term was not named by scholars until the 19th century, its foundations spanned centuries.

  5. In approximately 370 BC, Plato wrote Timaeus, stating that the “soul of the world is described as having these same musical ratios” and defining the initial concept of the sensory overlap, as well as the link with the spiritual world. Additionally, Aristotle, in 350 BC, related that the harmony of colors was much like the harmony of sounds, presenting a foundation for what would later emerge in the 1600s and beyond as correlation charts that married certain musical notes, devised by the Greek system of octaves (eight-note intervals), with a “like” color. Various discourses and treatises were written on these color tables. See Sean Day, “A Brief History of Synaesthesia and Music,” ThereminVox: Art, Technology and Gesture, February 21, 2001, http://www.thereminvox.com/article/articleview/33/5/5/. Robert Fludd, a 17th-century British scholar, also created a color chart based on Aristotle’s concepts. For more information, see Colorsystem: Colour Order Systems in Art and Science, http://www.colorsystem.com/?page_id=659&lang=en, adapted from Narciso Silvestrini, Ideefarbe (Zurich, 1994).

  6. From “Athanasius Kircher,” ThereminVox: Art, Technology and Gesture, February 4, 2004, http://www.thereminvox.com/article/articleview/77/1/16/.

  7. See Penelope Gouk’s helpful chapter “Making Music, Making Knowledge: The Harmonious Universe of Athanasius Kircher,” in The Great Art of Knowing: The Baroque Encyclopedia of Athanasius Kircher, ed. Daniel Stolzenberg (Stanford, 2001), 71–83, in particular 74.

  8. According to the findings in Ward’s study, Western synesthetes “read” and “hear” a painting from left to right and top to bottom, whereas Eastern synesthetes move right to left. See Jamie Ward, “Synestheisa,”Annual Review of Psychology 64 (January 2013), 49–75, https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-psych-113011-143840.

  9. Listen, for example, to Huygens Duo, “Klare, wat heeft er uw hartje verlept,” March 17, 2014, video, 1:47, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AupH0G9ofhs&pbjreload=10 (accessed September 12, 2017). This musical piece, composed by R. Merckaert, would have been a likely soundtrack to the lives of the subjects of these paintings, as well as the viewers of these intriguing scenes.